Discovering good movies, one bad movie at a time

Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
    • Rating Principles
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews
  • Top Picks
  • Members’ Corner
  • Blog

Disney has a villain problem

Posted by Conrado Falco Posted on Nov - 19 - 2018 0 Comment
Disney has a villain problem

Beware of spoilers for the last decade of Disney films – ed.

What’s your favorite Disney villain? When answering this question, most people will be able to rattle off a number of possibilities within seconds. Maleficent, Jafar, Captain Hook, Scar, Ursula, Cruella De Vil. There are so many options you’ll have a hard time narrowing your list to just one. The responses are totally different, however, when we tweak the question just a bit: What’s you favorite Disney villain of the past ten years? Suddenly the pool dries up and you’re left with Tangled‘s Mother Gothel (a superb villain in her own right) as the only reasonable option. These days, most Disney movies are saddled with utterly forgettable adversaries, and that’s if they feature a villain at all. Can you even remember the name of the main villain in Zootopia, Big Hero 6, or The Princess and the Frog? Villains have disappeared from Disney movies, and that’s a problem. Not because villains are essential to good cinema (although who doesn’t love a great villain?), but because the studio’s new approach to villainous characters points toward bigger problems in the way they make movies.

The main reason Disney hasn’t produced a memorable villain in almost a decade has to do with story structure. At some point in the past ten years, Disney Animation Studios his on a seemingly winning formula they refuse to let go. I call it the “Third Act Reveal Villain.” Here’s how it works: A seemingly harmless character is introduced in the first half of the movie -they can be a mentor, an authority figure, or a romantic interest. They spend most of the movie playing a supporting role until the third act comes along and they are revealed to have been a villain all along. This structure has become completely ubiquitous in Disney Animation. If we count both Disney and Pixar movies,  “Third Act Reveal Villain” has been used six times in the past seven years. That’s more than half the movies they’re released in that time.

On the one hand, it’s easy to see why Disney (and Pixar) would have gravitated toward this type of villain. There is something inherently satisfying in seeing the pieces of a puzzle come together, and holding off the identity of your villain until the end of the movie can be satisfying in the same way. This set-up works best when the villain’s identity not only comes as a surprise, but speaks to the themes of the movie. The best example of this is Frozen, in which the revelation that Hans is a heartless bastard reinforces the movie’s message about sisterhood. However, the people at Disney seem to use this set-up regardless of whether it fits in with the movie’s message. I guessed the identity of the Screensaver (the main villain in this year’s Incredibles 2) as soon as the character appeared on screen, and there was no essential reason why said identity had to be a secret. At this point, the revelation of who is a bad guy in a Disney movie is as predictable as the conclusion of a Scooby-Doo episode.

Why can’t Disney see that this once innovative structure has become a total hindrance? It has to do with the reason it began applying this structure in the first place. In the 2000s, Disney Animation Studios was floundering with flop after flop while Pixar was releasing one masterpiece after another. When Disney bought Pixar, head of animation John Lasseter decided to revitalize Disney Animation by applying the same principles that made Pixar such a success. Perhaps the most distinctive element of the Pixar method (other than their pioneering use of computer-generated animation) is the way they spend at least two years just breaking down the story of their movies. They want to make sure that every single nook and cranny is its place and that the story is completely satisfying. For a while, this method seemed flawless, resulting in one great movie after another, but more than two decades into the creation of Pixar, the results are starting to thin out. Pixar has grown more and more reliant on plot mechanics, resulting in movies that are overstuffed with plot and become wholly predictable. This was most apparent to me last year when the fact that I could see where we were heading from the minute the movie started made me feel like a heartless monster for not crying at the end of Coco.

The thing is, when you think about your favorite Disney movie, what do you remember about it? Is it the plot of the movie, or is it your favorite song, your favorite character, a wonderful set-piece. Animation is the medium of endless possibilities and it thrives when it can look beyond plot. A solid story is a strong foundation, but the greatest moments in animation occur when that foundation is used as a jumping off point onto something else. To character movement, to color, to bending shapes and bending minds. The two most indelible memories I have of Incredibles 2 are the incredibly chase-sequence with the Elasticycle and the hilarious brawl between Jack-Jack and that poor raccoon, neither of which are fundamental elements to the plot of the movie. If we’re talking about villains, think of the moment when Maleficent turns into a dragon, the way Cruela De Vil looks totally demented behind the wheel of her car, the cruelness of Scar leaving Mufasa to his death. “Third Act Reveal Villains” are plot twists, and plot twists have notoriously short shelf-lives. They get old minutes after they first occur. A great villain, on the other hand… those can last forever.

Conrado Falco is a New York-based playwright who loves movies. He publishes most of his film writing at CocoHitsNY, but the best way to keep up with him is to follow him on Twitter (@CocoHitsNewYork).

Categories:
Great Movies with Gay Characters Who Actually Do Gay Things
December 2018 movie preview
  • Subscribe

  • Connect With Us

    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Friday, February 15th, 2019 at 5:21am
    11 Valentine’s Days together. Time flies when you’re saving the world.

    ( @AlitaMovie review coming soon!) https://t.co/rsQ0aRNMpJ
    View on Twitter
    0
    0
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, February 14th, 2019 at 8:10am
    ‘The Garbage Pail Kids Movie’ from 1987 is only 100 minutes long, but every one of them is an agony to get through, offering no pleasure, no hint of good humor, nothing that's merely boring as opposed to excruciating.
    Read on: https://t.co/i3da22XU9T https://t.co/muX0XFp8vL
    View on Twitter
    0
    0
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Tuesday, February 12th, 2019 at 12:02pm
    ‘How To Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World’ - Race to theaters? Stream it? Or skip it altogether?
    https://t.co/gWteAsWkHQ

    #HowToTrainYourDragon3 https://t.co/tM5uYrWTM7
    View on Twitter
    1
    2
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, February 7th, 2019 at 12:13pm
    If you have ever spent time thinking, "I would really like to watch a version of John Wick that is a great deal shittier" you now have the luxury of watching ' #Polar', courtesy of @netflix
    Read on: https://t.co/7HuAsIUG5m https://t.co/suoyKc3PGP
    View on Twitter
    0
    3
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, February 7th, 2019 at 11:26am
    #StanAndOllie is built on the foundation of a love for the cinematic style of Stan Laurel & Oliver Hardy and while the film undoubtedly hits its goals, they are extraordinarily modest goals.
    Read on: https://t.co/PvWDl4y4XB https://t.co/r8kjjGVEbI
    View on Twitter
    0
    1
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, February 7th, 2019 at 6:25am
    #VelvetBuzzsaw Review: Nihilistic, sort of kitschy, and funny as hell.
    Read on: https://t.co/D4zUSgJ9HF https://t.co/vjpjZ3HPYl
    View on Twitter
    0
    1

    Alternate Ending

    Alternate Ending was formed when three friends realized they all shared a passion for movies. Our goal is to save you time and money by sharing our thoughts and recommendations on which movies to race to theaters for, which to watch at home and those to actively avoid. What makes Alternate Ending different from other film sites and podcasts? Well, we’re not 5 dudes in a room talking about our passion for Fight Club and Braveheart. We’re two dudes, and a lady, of which our tastes are quite varied. Rob, the film-school dropout, has seen an absurd amount of movies, and if we’re being honest, rounds out our Fight Club fan-base. Tim Brayton, our seasoned film critic, shares a more critical view of film, an appreciation for vintage cinema and perhaps limited-release movies that we might otherwise miss. Carrie, our casual movie-goer, reminds us all that cinema is in fact supposed to be fun and entertaining and that sometimes, just sometimes, happy endings are good. Too many film sites cater to the same kind of audience, with one overwhelming voice in the writing, but what we treasure at Alternate Ending is diversity: diversity of opinion, diversity in belief about what film should do and how it should do it. We want to celebrate our different opinions, and celebrate yours as well. This isn't a site for people who just want to talk about the latest hot new movies in theaters right this minute. This is a place for people who can't get to the theater until the third week a film is out; a place for people who just want to find something great to stream online after the kids have gone to sleep, a place for people whose favorite pastime is to grab a bunch of classic films on DVD from the library and watch them all weekend. It's a place that believes that every great movie is a wonderful new treasure, whether you see it the night of its premiere or fifty years later. It's a site about discovering good movies... one bad movie at a time. Join us for our weekly review of movies worth seeing, worth avoiding and our Top 5 lists – and don’t forget to play along at www.alternateending.com.
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingFriday, February 15th, 2019 at 8:10am
    11 Valentine’s Days together. Time flies when you’re saving the world.

    (‘Alita: Battle Angel’ review coming next week!)
    18 2 1    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingTuesday, February 12th, 2019 at 1:18pm
    How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World movie review and our recommendations on how best to see it!

    Seen it? Tell us what you think!

    Don't forget to subscribe for weekly reviews, trailer reactions and top 5 videocasts --> youtu.be/vwsaFG76XHw
    Alternate Ending
    How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World - Movie Review
    4    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingThursday, February 7th, 2019 at 4:00pm
    If you have ever spent time thinking, "I would really like to watch a version of John Wick that is a great deal shittier" you now have the luxury of watching 'Polar', courtesy of Netflix.
    Alternate Ending
    Polar (2019) - Movie Review
    John Ick - A grotesque action film that demonstrates no creativity or originality while providing tasteless, unthrilling thrills. Read the review!
    alternateending.com
    6    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingThursday, February 7th, 2019 at 2:29pm
    'Stan and Ollie' is built on the foundation of a love for the cinematic style of Stan Laurel & Oliver Hardy and while the film undoubtedly hits its goals, they are extraordinarily modest goals.
    Alternate Ending
    Stan & Ollie (2018) - Movie Review
    Another Nice Mess - Full of love for its subjects and terrifically well-acted, but it otherwise hits all of the normal biopic notes. Read the review!
    alternateending.com
    5    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingMonday, February 4th, 2019 at 2:40pm
    It's Livecast time!

    You've never seen a face as red as Carrie's, when Tim shares his favorite quote from 'The Favourite'.

    Join in on the awkwardness and fun as we pick our best and worst movies of 2018!
    youtu.be/I24jaqZGhMc
    6 1    View on Facebook
  • Support The Show





Copyright © 2019 Alternate Ending - Discovering good movies, one bad movie at a time.
WordPress Development by Gibson Web Development
This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.

CHANCE TO WIN $150 IN MOVIE THEATER GIFT CARDS

CAST YOUR BALLOT!