Discovering good movies, one bad movie at a time

Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
    • Rating Principles
  • Podcasts
  • Reviews
  • Videos
  • Patreon
  • Blog

Andrei Tarkovsky’s student films (1956-’61)

Posted by Tim Brayton Posted on May - 5 - 2020 0 Comments

Before he became the most internationally renowned Russian director since the silent era, Andrei Tarkovsky was just one more student at VGIK (Vserossijskij Gosudarstvennyj Institut Kinematografii, or the All-Union State Institute of Film), the film school of the Soviet Union that produced nearly all of the country’s significant filmmakers for generations. Here, he directed or co-directed three projects. We consider these today


The Killers (1956, co-directed with Marika Beiku and Alexander Gordon)

The first scrap of extant film we have directed by Tarkovsky is historically significant for another reason as well: it’s the first approved VGIK project ever to be based on a work of foreign literature. The first Russian-language collection of Ernest Hemingway stories had just been published in the Soviet Union, and Tarkovsky took it upon himself to beseech the school administration to permit him and his classmates to adapt 1927’s “The Killers”, a little snip of a tale in which two strange men show up at a diner looking for the man they’ve been hired to kill. One of the diner employees, recurring Hemingway character Nick Adams, tells the potential victim, and is confused to find that he has no interest in running, or doing much else.

It’s a tiny little anecdote shot through with weary existential melancholy, a perfect fit for a 19-minute student film (or to serve as the opening to a Hollywood feature, as had happened in 1946). The Killers, in the hands of Beiku, Gordon, and Tarkovsky, is very obviously little more than an exercise, though it’s an exercise that would make any film school teacher very proud – as indeed it did, winning much praise from the director Mikhail Romm, whose class the film had been made for. Story-wise, all the young filmmakers did was to stay out of Hemingway’s way, using his dialogue verbatim (or as close to verbatim as I can tell from watching a subtitled Russian version of a story I’ve only read in English) and focusing instead on things like staging, composition, and pacing. The cast, made up of film students (Gordon and Tarkovsky both appear onscreen, the latter whistling an American jazz tune that apparently had vaguely anti-authoritarian connotations at that time), is sort of adorably ill-equipped to handle the material: Gordon himself, appearing as the diner’s owner George, is the only person who looks weathered enough to convince us that he’s an adult at all.

But that’s not the exercise. The exercise is in executing scenes, and this the filmmakers do with perfect success. Tarkovsky is known to be responsible for the majority of the footage, in the form of the very long opening scene in the diner, and it would be claiming too much to say that you can see the future genius hiding inside of this material. It’s perfectly good, but not anything more. The most interesting thing about it is how very slow he’s willing to let the scene play out, in wide shots with no movement nor cutting. Given how much of the director’s future career would involve glacially-slow movies perfectly designed to test the viewer’s patience, it amuses me a great deal that he’d already be playing around with that. In this case, though, it’s not slow cinema for its own sake, but to set us up for the flurry of panic that happens when the diner employees are tied up by the killers, and several expressionistic angles are thrown in to give us a sense of their helplessness and confusion. It’s smart filmmaking, but not in any particular way original or innovative. It proves that Tarkovsky knows how to set up a camera to capture people moving in depth, and to trust his images without throwing a lot of razzle-dazzle at the viewer (though there is some razzle-dazzle), and this is an important thing to have proved. But if one-third of the team hadn’t gone on to become a pantheon-level director, there’s no way we’d be looking back on this one half a century later.

RATING:


There Will Be No Leave Today (1959, co-directed with Aleksandr Gordon)

Tarkovsky and Gordon came to be promising students on the back of The Killers, and the first big test of that promise was this television propaganda film for the 14th anniversary of the German surrender on 9 May 1945. The goal here was to prove that the two were capable of making something straightforward and direct, a popularly accessible film for mass consumption on a patriotic holiday.

Given that excessively uninspiring prompt, I suppose it’s no surprise that they succeeded, though film students throughout history have fucked up easier assignments. Certainly, keeping things in the air and moving at a steady clip for 45 minutes couldn’t have been entirely mindless, particularly given that the directive to make this broadly enjoyable meant that they couldn’t rely on the slow, long takes that had fueled The Killers. Doubly so, given that There Will Be No Leave Today is a thriller, one that’s looking to be pretty breathtaking and intense for it’s entire length

The story was based on a real incident, how closely I don’t know. In Gordon and Tarkovsky’s hands, it becomes a tightly-plotted procedural: land is being torn up to dig a trench, and the man operating the crane digging a hole in the earth happens to notice that, with one more sweep, he’ll be knocking into some shells that were buried on this exact spot, 15 years ago. The tension starts immediately, as he calls the bureaucrat (Pytor Lyubeshkin) who’s in charge of this project, but the bureaucrat is busy dealing with an irritating whiner, complaining that his own project has been disrupted by the trench-building, and he keeps ignoring the phone call. Will he pick it up in time to… approve a temporary shut-down of the project that’s already shut down, I guess? And herein is the problem: the directors are so eager to prove that they can ratchet up the tension and sustain it for an entire (short) film that they fail to judiciously consider whether the tension needs to be this intense, this quickly. It’s the most student film-ey gambit in this student film: once you find something that works, you just go and go  and go and go for it, and to hell with any restraint. It’s like a chef who drowns everything in truffle oil, or a composer who won’t let up on the French horns.

Speaking of music: There Will Be No Leave Today is absolutely shameless in how much it allows the score, by Yuri Matskevich, to plow forward and build tension. It’s the most hammy and indiscriminate part of the film, enough so that it routinely overwhelms the more graceful tension of the close-ups and high angles that the filmmakers use to build tension visually.

Still, for all that, it works. It works like a cudgel, mechanically effective without artistry, but even with the music threatening to tip the whole thing all the way over into camp, I found myself suitably carried away by the energy, the way the bright lighting seems to intensify the characters’ stress, and the great use of offscreen space at the climax, when all that tension finally culminates in an explosion. That this is a student film is clear, bleeding through some of the talky dialogue and flat performances, and there’s at least one cinematography error that has been left in the movie (a tilt that anticipates a character standing up by too much). It’s an exercise in making something that’s easy to watch and exciting, and it feels like that every bit. But I still hope they got top marks – it’s a successful exercise, after all.

RATING:


The Steamroller and the Violin (1961)

Tarkovsky’s thesis project, finished when he was 29 years old, is the work of a confident, mature filmmaker. It is not necessarily the work of the confident, mature filmmaker who would go on to make the seven feature films of Tarkovsky’s canon, mind you, though it’s not completely crazy that he’d go directly to Ivan’s Childhood from this (it’s not likely to be a coincidence that both films were co-written with Andrei Konchalovsky, whose collaboration with Tarkovsky ended after Andrei Rublev – which, to be fair, is a completely crazy place to go after this and Ivan). This, too, is a film about a childhood, or at least one day of a childhood. It’s a story about Sasha (Igor Fomchenko), a young boy taking violin lessons to appease his parents, and who finds the experience with his strict teacher suffocates his creativity rather than nurturing it. On this particular day, he’s made a new adult friend: Sergei (Vladimir Zamansky), the operator of a steamroller, who helps scare off a pack of bullies. Later on, the two take a walk around Moscow, while Sergei shares stories of his time in the war, while allowing Sasha to poke around with the steamroller.

It’s a quiet little thing, devoid of any particular conflict or narrative drive; this was by design. Tarkovsky wanted to show that he could make a pure mood pieces, looking to capture the feel of a day mucking around Moscow, and The Steamroller and the Violin is quite successful at this. Tarkovsky and cinematographer Vadim Yusov (who would go on to shoot the director’s first three features) use the grungy, grainy color film stock available to give the film a slightly warm quality that pulls it slightly but decisively out of the realm of realism, and in certain key moments – such as the sudden appearance of a great cathedral-like monument of Stalinist architecture behind a collapsing wall, gleaming with sun in a heroic shot that is probably the single most pro-Soviet image in Tarkovsky’s entire filmography – it feels very much like a children’s storybook. At other points, Tarkovsky and Yusov set Fomchenko and Zamansky in compositions that make the buildings and alleys of the city turn into a graphic pattern of lines and shadows, or use reflecting surfaces to split it into fragments of reality, folding in on itself, and in these moments, we see our best hint of the filmmaker to come, as he turns realistic spaces into a frame for the characters’ emotions. There’s a sense in which Sasha’s happy mood has already been pinned like  butterfly by the compositions, pleasant to look at but already fleeting in the moment we’re looking at it, accentuating the bittersweet mood of the story.

But not too bittersweet. This is not tragic film; it is, even, quite sweet and kind, celebrating the enthusiasm of childhood without sentimentalising it. The filmmakers don’t do anything to exaggerate Fomchenko as some kind of adorable moppet; they just let him look happy in takes that go on long enough to let his performance guide the rhythm of the film, rather than shape his performance through editing and cagily-chosen camera angles. It”s not quite as obsessed with stillness as The Killers, let alone the glacial films in the director’s future, but it does understand the importance of letting scenes between characters breathe and find their shape as they go along, rather than pressing them into a predetermined shape. It’s a generous and pleasant way to make a film, and it looks forward to a very different career than the one the director ended up having, but the basic strategy of living in moments rather than pushing through them would recur throughout Tarkovsky’s career. The Steamroller and the Violin is a well-made film rather than a visionary one, but it’s also well-made in a way that makes something more visionary possible.

RATING:

Categories:
The Alternate Ending Quarantine Film Festival, Month 2, or: A G'day to Die
2003: The Greatest Summer Movie Season of Them All
  • Subscribe

  • Connect With Us

    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Monday, January 25th, 2021 at 11:15pm
    Sundance Begins Early! Eight for Silver and Try Harder https://t.co/Dajun5eUK3
    View on Twitter
    0
    1
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Wednesday, January 20th, 2021 at 6:06pm
    New episode! 🥳

    It's not just any episode, it's our FAVORITE episode of the year! We agonize & we debate the BEST movies of 2020. It was a tough year in cinema, but nevertheless, we each came up with 10 great films.

    Tune in! 🎧 #Top10 #2020movies https://t.co/Iu42n5mFmm
    View on Twitter
    0
    1
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Tuesday, January 12th, 2021 at 1:25pm
    Movie Giveaway! 🎉

    We're BACK from Winter break with one of our FAVORITE episodes. We mull & we analyze our feelings & we pull together the best movies of 2020!

    But it's no fun if you don't play along, so tell us YOUR favorite movies of 2020 in the comments.

    #BestOf2020 https://t.co/i7wAhnZ2jK
    View on Twitter
    0
    2
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, December 17th, 2020 at 8:27pm
    New Episode! 🎧

    Top 5 Christmas Curmudgeons ➡️ https://t.co/oB2MpBiOse

    This one goes out to all of you who are feeling a bit grinchy about the holidays this year. We're sure this episode will have your heart growing AT LEAST 2 sizes. ❤

    Happy Holidays, from all of us at AE! https://t.co/a8LyJLBtYW
    View on Twitter
    1
    1
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Friday, December 11th, 2020 at 7:01pm
    Have you seen @OfficialRunFilm yet?!

    We sit down with director @aneeshchaganty to talk about his newest twisty-thriller, you won't want to miss it!

    🎧 https://t.co/nGuM0SIQzx

    Available on @hulu now! https://t.co/HY5oPbvyPG
    View on Twitter
    0
    1
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending @AlternateEndng
    Thursday, December 10th, 2020 at 1:33pm
    Movie Giveaway! 🥳

    Who is your favorite #Christmas Curmudgeon in a movie?

    To help our own hearts grow 2 1/2 sizes at the end of this tough year, share your favorites in the comments for a chance to win a free Amazon movie rental - the winner will be announced on Dec 14th! 🎉 https://t.co/b3GDZFGycf
    View on Twitter
    0
    2

    Alternate Ending

    Alternate Ending was formed when three friends realized they all shared a passion for movies. Our goal is to save you time and money by sharing our thoughts and recommendations on which movies to race to theaters for, which to watch at home and those to actively avoid. What makes Alternate Ending different from other film sites and podcasts? Well, we’re not 5 dudes in a room talking about our passion for Fight Club and Braveheart. We’re two dudes, and a lady, of which our tastes are quite varied. Rob, the film-school dropout, has seen an absurd amount of movies, and if we’re being honest, rounds out our Fight Club fan-base. Tim Brayton, our seasoned film critic, shares a more critical view of film, an appreciation for vintage cinema and perhaps limited-release movies that we might otherwise miss. Carrie, our casual movie-goer, reminds us all that cinema is in fact supposed to be fun and entertaining and that sometimes, just sometimes, happy endings are good. Too many film sites cater to the same kind of audience, with one overwhelming voice in the writing, but what we treasure at Alternate Ending is diversity: diversity of opinion, diversity in belief about what film should do and how it should do it. We want to celebrate our different opinions, and celebrate yours as well. This isn't a site for people who just want to talk about the latest hot new movies in theaters right this minute. This is a place for people who can't get to the theater until the third week a film is out; a place for people who just want to find something great to stream online after the kids have gone to sleep, a place for people whose favorite pastime is to grab a bunch of classic films on DVD from the library and watch them all weekend. It's a place that believes that every great movie is a wonderful new treasure, whether you see it the night of its premiere or fifty years later. It's a site about discovering good movies... one bad movie at a time. Join us for our weekly review of movies worth seeing, worth avoiding and our Top 5 lists – and don’t forget to play along at www.alternateending.com.
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate Ending was live.Tuesday, January 26th, 2021 at 2:15am
    Since we're cramming almost 40 movies over the course of the 5-days of #Sundance, we're seeing as many as possible in advance.

    On the docket tonight is #EightForSilver and Try Harder documentary

    Stay tuned for live reactions following embargoes.
    Alternate Ending
    Sundance Begins Early!
    1    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingTuesday, January 12th, 2021 at 4:22pm
    Movie Giveaway! 🎉

    We're BACK from Winter break with one of our FAVORITE episodes of the year. We mull, we agonize, we analyze our feelings and we pull together the best movies of 2020!

    But it's no fun if you don't play along, so tell us YOUR favorite movies of 2020 in the comments.

    We'll announce the winner of a free movie rental, when our first episode of 2021 airs on January 18th!

    #2020movies #Top10
    2    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingThursday, December 17th, 2020 at 9:22pm
    New Episode! 🎧

    Top 5 Christmas Curmudgeons ➡️bit.ly/3r5ukert

    This one goes out to all of you who are feeling a bit grinchy about the holidays this year. We're sure that this episode will have your heart growing AT LEAST 2 sizes. ❤

    Happy Holidays, from all of us at AE!
       View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingFriday, December 11th, 2020 at 9:58pm
    Have you seen Run Film yet?!

    We sit down with director Aneesh Chaganty to talk about his newest twisty-thriller, you won't want to miss it!

    🎧 bit.ly/2KeFZqg
    1    View on Facebook
    Alternate Ending
    Alternate EndingThursday, December 10th, 2020 at 4:28pm
    Movie Giveaway! 🥳

    Who is your favorite Christmas Curmudgeon in a movie?

    Almost as much as Santa Claus and reindeer, you can’t have a Christmas movie without some miserable SOB who starts out by humbugging their way through throngs of cheerful celebrants and has, by the end of the second hour, learned the True Meaning of Christmas. 🎄

    To help our own hearts grow two-and-a-half sizes at the end of this tough year, share your favorites in the comments below for a chance to win a free Amazon movie rental - the winner will be announced when our next episode airs on Dec 14th! ❤️
    1    View on Facebook
  • Support The Show

    Rent the Looks, Own the Style - The Mr. & Ms. Collection

    Rent the Looks, Own the Style - The Mr. & Ms. Collection

Copyright © 2021 Alternate Ending - Discovering good movies, one bad movie at a time.
WordPress Development by Gibson Web Development
This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.